SERTA · RESEARCH-BASED REVIEW
Five Star Mattress In A Box review
Treat each height-and-feel combination as a separate buying choice.
- Construction
- Innerspring
- Published feel
- Multiple heights and feels
- Home trial
- 100 nights
What sets it apart
Five Star uses individually wrapped coils and zoned support foam in a boxed mattress. Heights and top styles vary substantially.
Our take
Treat each height-and-feel combination as a separate buying choice. A price for the shortest version cannot describe the comfort stack of a much taller pillow top.
Reasons to consider it
A spring-centered build is worth comparing if you like a buoyant surface and change positions frequently.
The tradeoff
Spring response can make partner movement more noticeable. A pillow top changes cushioning but does not remove the underlying spring feel.
These comfort observations are editorial inferences from construction and published firmness, not results of hands-on testing.
Price and configurations
The recorded queen configurations span $319 to $1,119. The lowest amount applies to the least expensive configuration observed, not every firmness, height or cover.
Distinct observed queen prices. Multiple options can share one price; these amounts do not identify a firmness on their own.
For context, the Classic starts at $399 in this catalog, $80 more than Five Star Mattress In A Box. Compare the construction and firmness below before treating the difference as an upgrade.
Price snapshot: September 10, 2026. USD, before tax. Delivery, accessories, bases and later promotions can change your total.
Trial, returns and setup
The product information advertises 100 nights for the home trial on direct purchases. Check the required adjustment period, pickup or return fees, condition rules, eligible foundations and warranty exclusions. A retailer purchase may have different terms.
Sources and review approach
- Serta: product specifications and options
- Serta: original pricing source · recorded September 10, 2026
Specifications reviewed September 11, 2026. We use published product information and clearly identify our inferences. We have not slept on or lab-tested this mattress, and we do not assign fabricated test scores.
Shopping links on this page may be affiliate links. If you buy through an affiliate link, Bed Atlas may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Commission rates do not affect these reviews, our ratings, or the bed finder. Affiliate links are labeled next to the link. Read our full approach.